The i5 User-Capped Solution Editions Versus Windows Machines--For 40 Users  
i5 520 i5 520 HP ProLiant   i5 520 i5 520 HP ProLiant
SE Growth (7787) #1 Standard (0906) #2 DL380 G5 #1   SE Growth (7787) #2 Standard (0906) DL380 G5 #2
Processor Power5+ Power5+ Xeon 5120   Power5+ Power5+ Xeon 5120
Active Cores 1 1 2   2 2 4
CPU Speed 1.9 GHz 1.9 GHz 1.86 GHz   1.9 GHz 1.9 GHz 2 GHz
TPC-C TPM 37,800 37,800 40,810   70,645 70,645 70,200
CPW Rating 3,800 3,800 4,100   7,100 7,100 7,055
Base System Price $25,900 $35,100 $2,889   $27,700 $41,700 $3,750
 
Main Memory 4 GB 4 GB 4 GB   4 GB 4 GB 4 GB
Cost Integrated $2,320 $1,196   Integrated $2,320 $1,196
Base Disks 4 * 35 GB 15 K 4 * 35 GB 15 K 6 * SAS 36 GB 10 K   4 * 35 GB 15 K 4 * 35 GB 15 K 6 * SAS 36 GB 10 K
Cost Integrated $4,796 $1,674   Integrated $4,796 $1,674
RAID-5 Controller Feature 5727 Feature 5727 SmartArray 6404   Feature 5727 Feature 5727 SmartArray 6404
Cost Integrated $1,499 $1,299   Integrated $1,499 $1,299
Disk Bundles NA NA NA   NA NA NA
Capacity NA NA NA   NA NA NA
Cost NA NA NA   NA NA NA
Total Capacity 142 GB 142 GB 216 GB   142 GB 142 GB 216 GB
 
Hardware Subtotal $25,900 $43,715 $5,862   $27,700 $50,315 $6,723
Estimated Retail $22,792 $38,469 $5,862   $24,376 $44,277 $6,723
 
Operating System i5/OS V5R4 i5/OS V5R4 Windows 2003 EE R2   i5/OS V5R4 i5/OS V5R4 Windows 2003 EE R2
Cost Integrated Integrated $3,999   $21,000 $21,000 $3,999
User Licenses 40 Unlimited (170 Est) 40   40 Unlimited (315 Est) 40
Cost Integrated Integrated $995 for 15 more   Integrated Integrated $995 for 15 more
Database DB2/400 DB2/400 SQL Server 2005 SE   DB2/400 DB2/400 SQL Server 2005 SE
Cost Integrated Integrated $5,999   Integrated Integrated $11,998
Partitioning Hypervisor Virtualization Engine Virtualization Engine VMware ESX Server EE   Virtualization Engine Virtualization Engine VMware ESX Server EE
Cost Integrated Integrated $5,750   Integrated Integrated $5,750
System Cost $22,792 $38,469 $16,855   $45,376 $65,277 $23,715
 
Cost Per CPW $6.00 $10.12 $4.11   $6.39 $9.19 $3.36
Cost Per User $569.80 $226.29 $421.38   $1,134.40 $207.23 $592.88
i5 SE Percent Savings 46.6%   30.5%
 
Note: All i5 Power5+ machines have the first year of Software Maintenance (SWMA) bundled into the hardware  
price. The HP ProLiant box above has a 24x7, onsite maintenance contract sold with the hardware, and  
Microsoft includes patch support with its Windows licenses.  


Copyright © 1996-2008 Guild Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guild Companies, Inc., 50 Park Terrace East, Suite 8F, New York, NY 10034

Privacy Statement