Volume 5, Number 22 -- June 3, 2008

Tape Backup: Obviously, a Whole Lot Greener than Disk Backup

Published: June 3, 2008

by Timothy Prickett Morgan

Some technologies are very hard to kill. Long before there was disk, there was tape, and the ridiculously cheap disk capacity that is available has allowed many companies to do their archiving on disk-based archiving systems that look like tape to servers even if they are not. But using disk-based archiving comes at a very high operational cost. Disks need to spin to be useful, but once a tape has data archived on it, it pretty much stops using power until it is specifically required to get a bit of data for an application or to archive another data set.

The death of tape has been predicted many times in the past, probably as much as the mainframe that it was initially married to. But tape still has its uses, and if history is any guide, will continue to. The Ultrium consortium, the group of tape drive and array makers that is backing the high-density Linear Tape Out (LTO) tape technology that pretty much owns the data center these days, is touting a new report put out by The Clipper Group that compares the cost of disk-based archiving versus tape archiving, including not only the cost of the media itself but also the energy costs associated with using it. (You can read that report here for yourself at the Ultrium consortium site.)

The bottom line, according to analysts David Reine and Mike Kahn, is that the cost of long-term storage for an array of SATA disks is 24 times as high compared to LTO-4 tape arrays, and the energy costs for the disk backup is 290 times higher. You might think that with disk drives getting fatter and arrays getting less expensive, that a disk-to-disk (D2D) backup setup would be more appealing that a tape library. "We began this study to see if the decreasing costs of disk subsystems and the increasing capacity of disk drives, especially second-tier SATA storage, might have made the TCO for disk more attractive versus tape in the long-term storage of data," the two analysts explained in the report. "It did not. We thought that the cost of energy would be a noticeable factor in favor of tape. And it is."

Clipper Group took an initial data set of 50 TB and assumed that the capacity requirements for the midrange shop being simulated would grow by 50 percent per year. The data center did daily incremental backups to disk and tape, retaining these on disk for a quarter and then moved out to disk array archives or a tape library. The cost comparison that Clipper Group did only examined the cost of these archives, not including the initial disk arrays, over a five-year term. While electricity in major metro centers is now in the range of 20 cents per kilowatt-hour, Clipper Group chose 12 cents per kilowatt-hour, which is closer to the prevailing cost in rural areas for corporations. (But certainly not the residential rate we pay in our homes, which is higher.) To simplify things, the cost of electricity was held constant over the five years, but it seems unlikely that this will happen out here in reality.

The price differences between the two solutions--D2D or tape library--are jaw dropping. The five-year cost for the D2D approach is $51.7 million, with $49.9 million of that coming from the hardware and software, $1.2 million coming from electricity costs, and just under $600,000 coming from space costs. (Machines have to pay rent, too.) The tape library to do the same backups costs $1.79 million, with only $344,250 coming from space costs and a ridiculously small $3,416 in energy costs over five years.

What disk-based archiving solution providers have figured out, and what disk array makers are thinking about too, is to design a disk array that can quiesce disk arms and platters within the array when they are not needed. Of course, with random access to data, this is something of a challenge, and probably not the right engineering solution.

That is why I suspect that flash memory arrays will be making waves as a third option for nearline archiving as soon as reasonably fat flash memory chips are available. Last week, for instance, Intel announced a 32 gigabit NAND flash memory chip that uses the company's most advanced 34 nanometer chip making processes. These chips, as well as similar 32 gigabit flash chips from Toshiba and Samsung, are going to allow disk makers to offer solid state storage disks in a 1.8-inch form factor with a 256 GB capacity. Let that sink in for a while.

And now consider that flash uses a lot less power, is more reliable than disks thanks to the lack of moving parts, and has anywhere from one to two orders of magnitude higher I/O operations per second (IOPs) compared to regular disk drives. So on I/O bound workloads--like transaction processing--a mix of relatively expensive flash drives backed up by tape for archiving could be very energy efficient and cost-effective compared to a disk array setup with disk-based archiving. Flash provides the performance and tape provides the price/performance. Flash-based disk drives have to go volume and the price has to come down before this can happen, but with the world moving to laptops, the transition away from disks to flash drives could happen pretty quickly, bringing the costs way down as the volumes go way up.


IT Shops Consume 2 Million LTO Tape Drives

IBM Introduces Half-Height LTO 3 Tape Drive

IBM Rolls Out LTO 4 Tape Drives and Libraries

Asigra Debuts Remote, Agent-Less Backup for iSeries

HP Buys Clustering Software Maker, Launches D2D Backup Solution

LTO Tape Drives a Smashing Success

Idealstor Adds CDP to Backup Repertoire That Includes 'Ejectable' Disks

Unitrends Adds OS/400 Support to D2D Backup Appliances

                     Post this story to
               Post this story to Digg
    Post this story to Slashdot

Sponsored By

Vibrant is a leading source for
IBM Power Systems and Upgrades.

We offer factory refurbished systems at deep discounts off IBM's list price,
and all systems are guaranteed eligible for IBM maintenance.

Systems and upgrades are offered for the following systems:
Power6, P5, P4, RS6000, i5, AS/400 and IBM Blades

Editor: Timothy Prickett Morgan
Contributing Editors: Dan Burger, Joe Hertvik, Kevin Vandever,
Shannon O'Donnell, Victor Rozek, Hesh Wiener, Alex Woodie
Publisher and Advertising Director: Jenny Thomas
Advertising Sales Representative: Kim Reed
Contact the Editors: To contact anyone on the IT Jungle Team
Go to our contacts page and send us a message.

Sponsored Links

Storix:  Easily recover an entire system onto dissimilar hardware with SBAdmin for Linux and AIX
COMMON:  Join us at the annual 2009 conference, April 26 - April 30, in Reno, Nevada is the resource for job transitions after age 40


IT Jungle Store Top Book Picks

Getting Started with PHP for i5/OS: List Price, $59.95
The System i RPG & RPG IV Tutorial and Lab Exercises: List Price, $59.95
The System i Pocket RPG & RPG IV Guide: List Price, $69.95
The iSeries Pocket Database Guide: List Price, $59.00
The iSeries Pocket Developers' Guide: List Price, $59.00
The iSeries Pocket SQL Guide: List Price, $59.00
The iSeries Pocket Query Guide: List Price, $49.00
The iSeries Pocket WebFacing Primer: List Price, $39.00
Migrating to WebSphere Express for iSeries: List Price, $49.00
iSeries Express Web Implementer's Guide: List Price, $59.00
Getting Started with WebSphere Development Studio for iSeries: List Price, $79.95
Getting Started With WebSphere Development Studio Client for iSeries: List Price, $89.00
Getting Started with WebSphere Express for iSeries: List Price, $49.00
WebFacing Application Design and Development Guide: List Price, $55.00
Can the AS/400 Survive IBM?: List Price, $49.00
The All-Everything Machine: List Price, $29.95
Chip Wars: List Price, $29.95

The Four Hundred
More Power Transitions Are on the Way

U.S. Drags Down Server Sales in Q1, But Weak Dollar Helps

Server Branding 101: Big Name, Big Game?

Java Compute Appliances Upgraded by Azul Systems

Survival of the Fittest: Ensuring IT Is Providing You with an Innovative Edge

Four Hundred Stuff
Paglo Aims to be the Google of IT Management

RPG Programmer Avoids 'Learn Java or Flip Burgers' Pitfall

Lieberman Adds i OS Support to Password Program

KST Offers DataTrigger to Protect DB2/400 Files

Kisco Clamps Down on FTP Exposure with SafeNet/400

Big Iron
Reseller Mainline to Acquire Competitor Cornerstone

Top Mainframe Stories From Around the Web

Chats, Webinars, Seminars, Shows, and Other Happenings

Four Hundred Guru
Use PCOMM Scripts to Dynamically Build a Spreadsheet, Part 2

Use SQL to Strip Out Tab Characters

Admin Alert: Monitoring the Monitors

System i PTF Guide
May 31, 2008: Volume 10, Number 22

May 24, 2008: Volume 10, Number 21

May 17, 2008: Volume 10, Number 20

May 10, 2008: Volume 10, Number 19

May 3, 2008: Volume 10, Number 18

April 26, 2008: Volume 10, Number 17

The Windows Observer
Microsoft Reverses Course, Opens Office to ODF

Intel and Itanium Partners Gear Up for Quad-Core Tukwilas

Hyper-V RC1 Released as Microsoft Shares Performance Data

Paglo Aims to be the Google of IT Management

The Server Biz Enjoys the X64 Upgrade Cycle in Q1

The Unix Guardian
The Unix Competition Is Still as Heated as Ever

The Server Biz Enjoys the X64 Upgrade Cycle in Q1

Intel and Itanium Partners Gear Up for Quad-Core Tukwilas

As I See It: The Programmer as Artist

Reseller Mainline to Acquire Competitor Cornerstone

Four Hundred Monitor
Four Hundred Monitor's
Full iSeries Events Calendar


Guild Companies
Vibrant Technologies

Printer Friendly Version

Novell Swings to a Tiny Profit on a Tiny Revenue Bump in Q2

U.S. Drags Down Server Sales in Q1, But Weak Dollar Helps

Intel and Itanium Partners Gear Up for Quad-Core Tukwilas

Java Compute Appliances Upgraded by Azul Systems

Server Branding 101: Big Name, Big Game?

But Wait, There's More:

Servers, Storage, Laptops and Weak Dollars Buoy Dell in Q1 . . . HP Sets Up Cloud-HPC Computing Unit, Launches Two Server Blade . . . Three Users Groups for HP Customers Merge . . . Interesting Mods and Add-Ons for Office Blade Servers . . . Tape Backup: Obviously, a Whole Lot Greener than Disk Backup . . .

The Linux Beacon


Subscription Information:
You can unsubscribe, change your email address, or sign up for any of IT Jungle's free e-newsletters through our Web site at

Copyright © 1996-2008 Guild Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guild Companies, Inc., 50 Park Terrace East, Suite 8F, New York, NY 10034

Privacy Statement