Newsletters   Subscriptions  Forums  Store   Career  Media Kit  About Us  Contact  Search   Home 
two
Volume 2, Number 16 -- April 20, 2005

Skepticism of Microsoft-Sponsored Study Applauded


Feedback on "What Does Microsoft's Latest Windows-Versus-Linux Test Show?"

Alex, you do well to be skeptical of Microsoft's benchmarks.

Writing scripts to make the tape drive work? Normally you're unlucky if you have to manually choose a kernel module to run a tape drive. A strong odour of rat pervades all.

This sounds like another MindCraft fiasco, comparing Macks with Ladas by doing time trials and handling tests, then timing the drivers as they change a wheel or wash down their vehicles.

There's another obvious ploy here as Microsoft persist in choosing only the expensive and conservative RAHS3 to benchmark against, whereas in real life quite a number of $0 Linux distributions like Debian Testing or Mandrake (now Mandriva) Community will do a better, faster, easier job.

If you feel inclined to pay for something, put it directly into support, donate it - or offer a code bounty on a feature you'd like. Can you imagine Microsoft's reaction if you offered them five grand to add PDF exporting to MS Word by June? Yet some businesses save ten times that, each, on that one feature alone when they elect to use OpenOffice.org in place of or alongside Microsoft Office.

The big issue is control. Microsoft feel impressed to control the benchmarks to uselessness rather than playing on a level field, because that inward-directed control is an essential part of their core motivations. It means that they can never grant you or any other business the independence you automatically get from their opponents on the other bench. I haven't seen that valued or benchmarked yet. It's a sleeping giant - or was.

Thank you for taking the time to point out some of the un-publicised aspects of the study, and without assuming an adversorial position. It's an unusually calm and rational attitude in the trade press.

--Leon

Thanks for writing in, Leon. We think it's important to provide critical analysis of studies, particularly when they're sponsored by one of the vendors featured in the study. Valuable insights into market trends can be gleaned from well-done studies, but all too often key elements of fact are glossed over or buried, or the studies parameters are so narrow as to make it practically impossible to assess the value of the study's results in the real world.

--Alex

We value your feedback and insights. Feel free to send a letter to the editor. Letters may be printed, unless otherwise specified, and edited for clarity or length. SEND FEEDBACK >


Sponsored By
VISION SOLUTIONS

Vision Solutions will be coming
to a city near you with the
SQL Sever 2005 Road show
showcasing ORION Integrator.

ORION Integrator provides real-time,
bi-directional data replication, integration,
transformation and filtering across multiple
operating systems and databases
including Oracle, Sybase, Microsoft SQL Server,
and IBM DB2.

Click on the SQL banner at
www.orionintegrator.com
to register now!


Editor: Alex Woodie
Contributing Editors: Dan Burger, Joe Hertvik, Shannon O'Donnell,
Timothy Prickett Morgan, Victor Rozek, Kevin Vandever, Hesh Wiener
Publisher and Advertising Director: Jenny Thomas
Advertising Sales Representative: Kim Reed
Contact the Editors: To contact anyone on the IT Jungle Team
Go to our contacts page and send us a message.


THIS ISSUE
SPONSORED BY:

Vision Solutions
Hewlett-Packard
Stalker Software
Thawte Consulting
Winternals Software


The Windows Observer

BACK ISSUES

TABLE OF
CONTENTS
Microsoft Senses the Finish Line for "Whidbey" and "Yukon"

Unisys Delivers Clustering Solution for Windows

X64 Version of Windows Server 2003 on Tap from Microsoft

Microsoft Issues Public Beta of Microsoft Data Protection Manager

But Wait, There's More

Skepticism of Microsoft-sponsored Study Applauded


The Four Hundred
IBM Beefs Up iSeries Disk Arrays, I/O Options

IBM Offers HMC-Less iSeries Linux Partitioning

IBM Comes Up Short in Q1 After March Fall Off

The Linux Beacon
HP to Super-Size Superdome with Arches Chipset

Azul Gets Aggressive with Java Appliances

Cisco Buys InfiniBand/Virtualization Specialist Topspin for $250 Million

The Unix Guardian
Sun Books Tiny Loss as Sales Decline 1 Percent in Q3

HP to Super-Size Superdome with Arches Chipset

Apple Goes 64-Bit with Tiger Release of OS X


Copyright © 1996-2008 Guild Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guild Companies, Inc. (formerly Midrange Server), 50 Park Terrace East, Suite 8F, New York, NY 10034
Privacy Statement