• The Four Hundred
  • Subscribe
  • Media Kit
  • Contributors
  • About Us
  • Contact
Menu
  • The Four Hundred
  • Subscribe
  • Media Kit
  • Contributors
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • IBM Piles on the Patents, Promises to Publish Plenty

    January 19, 2009 Dan Burger

    Can anyone remember a time when IBM wasn’t the dominate technology company when it comes to patents? This is the 16th consecutive year that Big Blue has piled up more patents than any of its competitors. Sixteen years is a long time for anyone to stay on top of anything. IBM makes it look easy. It removed the element of suspense in this annual announcement a long time ago. No one asks “Who won?” It’s more like: “How many patents did they get this year?”

    In 2008, IBM was awarded 4,186 U.S. patents. No company has ever crossed the 4,000-patent threshold before. Rivals Microsoft (2,030 patents) and Intel (1,776 patents) ranked fourth and fifth in this contest, but their combined number of patents could not match IBM. Microsoft’s patent total climbed compared to 2007. Intel’s slid.

    Of course, IBM sent out a press release tooting its own horn while happily (my assumption) noting it had slapped Hewlett-Packard–the largest high tech company in the world based on sales–with a three-to-one patent differential. HP (1,424 patents) was ranked 10th on the patent leader board.

    According to the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, 157,774 patents were granted in 2008, which was a slim increase over the 157,248 granted the year before.

    Although IBM put some monumental numbers on the board, the statistic that is causing tongues to wag is that only 49 percent of the patents were granted to U.S. businesses. That makes 2008 the first year that less than half of the patents granted by the USPTO were designated to red, white, and blue organizations. You’ll also find the top 10 patent-grabbing companies in 2008 are no longer dominated by U.S. businesses. Japan has five of the top 10, while the USA has four. All is not lost just yet, however. After counting all the new patents, U.S.-based companies remain on top. Following up are Japan, Germany, South Korea, and Taiwan.

    But that won’t stop “brain drain” from being a hot topic in the blogosphere, around the office break rooms, and maybe even the halls of Congress. Has the fountain of math and science whiz kids born in the USA all but dried up? Using patent awards as the measuring stick, there seems to be a continuing drought. The questions to be debated, however, are will U.S. companies continue to fade in terms of intellectual stamina and will anything be done to regain it? That’s a boiling pot and there are plenty of people stirring it. But not me, not today. May I suggest you bug Timothy Prickett Morgan about this topic? He opens and eats a can a worms for breakfast every day. This country’s collective, but shriveling, engineering brain power is a topic I’m sure he would enjoy.

    Right now there’s more to this story about IBM’s cache of patents.

    How would you expect IBM to cash in its cache? Intellectual property is worth a fortune, right? Yes, it is, but not entirely in the old school proprietary scenario that first comes to mind. IBM, a company not particularly well known for its altruism, says it will make more of its patents public than it will keep private. In 2009, we should see somewhere in the vicinity of 3,000 of its patented technical inventions published, which means they become public property. The company press release claims this is an increase of 50 percent over the number of technical inventions it previously made available in any one year. Worthy of some back patting, I would say, even if these will feather the nest in areas such as infrastructure, open source software, and software interoperability–along the lines that IBM prefers to see those things go.

    As IBM sees it, the publication of its chosen patents “protects inventors from allegations of infringement by placing the intellectual property into the body of prior art. Publications also improve patent quality, since they can be cited by patent offices in limiting the scope of patent applications. Publication also helps spur follow-on innovation that ensures dynamic business growth.”

    That’s very generous, but at the same time, you can bet IBM will continue to be very protective–as it should be–of a great number of its patents new and old. Last time I checked, Santa Claus didn’t wear a dark blue suit, but he also doesn’t give everybody everything they want. Here’s how “Sometimes Santa” views the situation.

    “IBM’s leadership in the strategic use of intellectual property is based on balancing proprietary and open innovation,” said explained John Kelly, senior vice president and director of IBM Research. “Our goal is helping stimulate innovation as public investments in large infrastructure projects are being planned to boost global economies. We also anticipate that adding additional transparency to the patent system will help tackle the continuing patent quality crisis, which is impeding inventors, entrepreneurs and companies of all sizes.”

    To demonstrate that Big Blue is truly in a giving mood, the company also noted that it would contribute statistical and analytical tools to the open source community. The tools, developed at IBM Research, were designed to measure the quality of patents–an issue that many regard as the reason the patent process is both slow and plagued by legal challenges. Rick Lawrence, manager of predictive modeling for IBM Research, emphasized the importance of working with the academic and legal communities on patent quality initiatives to increase the effectiveness of the patent system and encourage the patenting of “truly important innovations.”

    IBM researchers, by the way, are part of a Patent Quality Index (PQI) project focused on the issue of patents that are of questionable quality and the backlogs they create, intellectual property rights, and the increased speculation and litigation created by these factors.

    While we’re on the topic of generosity, I’ll be generous, too, and make believe that all of IBM’s 4,186 patents last year were of the highest quality–especially the intellectual property in those patents to be made public. Regardless, I figure it’s not the gift that counts. It’s the thought, right?

    The fact that IBM is giving away anything is a bit surprising. Question the company’s motives if you must, but obtaining this intellectual property isn’t cheap and it isn’t often turned over to the world. Interest in protecting intellectual property, both in the United States and abroad, is on an up-swing according to the research firm IFI Patent Intelligence. (IFI actually does the patent counting these days; USPTO stopped issuing releases a few years back.)

    In a statement, Darlene Slaughter, general manager of IFI, said “although data suggest that American companies garnered a minority share of the total number of corporate U.S. patents last year, it’s important not to confuse quantity with quality. What’s clear is that many of the world’s largest companies are placing a higher priority on protecting their intellectual property.” She went on to say, “Securing patents may be even more important in a down economy, since it gives patent holders an edge over their competitors.”

    In a down economy, we’ll take what we can get.

    RELATED STORIES

    Microsoft Rises to Sixth on Patent List for 2007

    Patently Absurd: IBM Tries to Patent Outsourcing, Then Kills It

    IBM Wins U.S. Patent Count Again as Vendors Build Up Patent War Chests

    Patent Depending

    IBM Tops U.S. Patent List for 13th Straight Year



                         Post this story to del.icio.us
                   Post this story to Digg
        Post this story to Slashdot

    Share this:

    • Reddit
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Email

    Tags: Tags: mtfh_rc, Volume 18, Number 3 -- January 19, 2009

    Sponsored by
    PERFSCAN

    Revolutionary Performance Management Software

    At Greymine, we recognize there is a void in the IT world for a dedicated performance management company and also for a performance management tool that’s modern, easy to use, and doesn’t cost an arm and a leg. That’s why we created PERFSCAN.

    PERFSCAN is designed to make your job easier. With revolutionary technology, an easy-to-read report and graphics engine, and real time monitoring, tasks that used to take days can now take minutes. This means you will know your system better and will be able to provide better service to your customers.

    OUR FEATURES

    PERFSCAN is full of robust features that don’t require you to take a three-day class in order to use the product effectively.

    Customizable Performance Reporting

    Whether you are troubleshooting a major system problem or simply creating a monthly report, PERFSCAN lets you select any combination of desired performance metrics (CPU, Disk, and Memory).

    User Defined Performance Guidelines

    No matter if you are a managed service provider managing complex systems in the cloud or a customer analyzing your on-premises solution, PERFSCAN gives you the flexibility to define all mission critical guidelines how they need to be.

    Understanding The Impact Of Change

    Tired of all the finger pointing when performance is suffering? PERFSCAN’s innovative What’s Changed and Period vs. Period analysis creates a culture of proof by correlating known environmental changes with system performance metrics.

    Comprehensive Executive Summary

    Creating performance graphs is easy. Understanding what they mean is another thing. With one mouse click, PERFSCAN includes an easy-to-understand executive summary for each core metric analyzed.

    Combined Real-Time Monitor And Performance Analysis Tool

    With PERFSCAN’s combined built in enterprise real-time monitor and historical performance analysis capability, you will always know how your mission-critical systems are performing.

    Cloud Performance Reporting Is Easy

    Managing performance for production systems in the cloud can be a black hole to many system administrators. The good news is PERFSCAN analyzes all core metrics regardless of the location. That’s why MSPs and customers love PERFSCAN.

    Detailed Job Analysis

    PERFSCAN shows detailed top job analysis for any desired period. All metrics are displayed in two ways: Traditional Report and Percentage Breakdown Pie Chart. This toggle capability instantly shows the jobs using the most system resources.

    Save Report Capability

    Your boss lost the report you gave to him on Friday. Now what do you do? With PERFSCAN’s save report capability, any report can be retrieved in a matter of seconds.

    Professional PDF Reporting With Branding

    Creating professional looking reports for your customers has never been easier with PERFSCAN. Branding for our partners and service provider customers is easy with PERFSCAN.

    Check it out at perfscan.com

    Share this:

    • Reddit
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Email

    Admin Alert: Looking for i5/OS Trouble, Part II Jobscope’s Customer Focus is Made-to-Order

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

TFH Volume: 18 Issue: 3

This Issue Sponsored By

    Table of Contents

    • AS/400 LUG: Friends in High Places
    • Global 2009 IT Spending Will be Up, Down, Forrester Says
    • IBM Piles on the Patents, Promises to Publish Plenty
    • As I See It: Test of Character
    • IBM Helps Partners Sell Software to Midrange Shops
    • Small Biz Owners Are Sticking It Out, Survey Says
    • IBM Cuts Back on Discounts on Power Systems i-DS8000 Deals
    • Freeborders Expands its AS/400 Tech Center
    • IBM Talks Up Notes/Domino Numbers
    • Server-Printer Combo Deal Results from IBM-Ricoh Alliance

    Content archive

    • The Four Hundred
    • Four Hundred Stuff
    • Four Hundred Guru

    Recent Posts

    • Fortra Issues 20th State of IBM i Security Report
    • FNTS Launches Managed Services for Power Servers in IBM Cloud
    • Total LTO Shipped Capacity Up Slightly in 2022
    • Four Hundred Monitor, May 24
    • Update On Critical Security Vulnerability In PowerVM
    • Critical Security Vulnerability In PowerVM Hypervisor
    • IBM Power: Hosted On-Premises Or In The Cloud?
    • Guru: Watch Out For This Pitfall When Working With Integer Columns
    • As I See It: Bob-the-Bot
    • IBM i PTF Guide, Volume 25, Number 21

    Subscribe

    To get news from IT Jungle sent to your inbox every week, subscribe to our newsletter.

    Pages

    • About Us
    • Contact
    • Contributors
    • Four Hundred Monitor
    • IBM i PTF Guide
    • Media Kit
    • Subscribe

    Search

    Copyright © 2023 IT Jungle