• The Four Hundred
  • Subscribe
  • Media Kit
  • Contributors
  • About Us
  • Contact
Menu
  • The Four Hundred
  • Subscribe
  • Media Kit
  • Contributors
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • JDA Software’s i2 Unit Smacked with $246 Million Judgment

    June 21, 2010 Timothy Prickett Morgan

    JDA Software didn’t try to acquire supply chain software specialist i2 Technologies once, but twice–first in August 2008 for $346 million, an attempt that failed, and again in November 2009 for $396 million. Whoever did the due diligence as part of the merger and reckoned the effect of a lawsuit between the Dillard’s department store chain and i2 did not reckon on the jury in the District Court of the State of Texas for the County of Dallas, which came to the conclusion that i2 had not met its software license agreements and awarded $246 million in damages.

    Yeah, you heard that number right. And considering that JDA didn’t even close the i2 deal until January 28 of this year, it seems particularly harsh in a cosmic sense.

    According to the statement put out by JDA last week, the Dallas jury awarded $8 million in actual damages to Dillard’s to cover the cost of two i2 supply chain programs that the retailer acquired in 2000. The jury then awarded Dillard’s another $238 million in what JDA characterized as “alleged consequential, special or punitive damages.” JDA was aghast at the ruling, saying that the jury awarded the damages to Dillard’s even though the company formally accepted the i2 programs and used them for several years before filing a lawsuit and continues to use one of the programs to this day. Moreover, the software at issue has been used by other “national and global customers” of i2 for several years, according to JDA, so it is a bit baffled as to why the Little Rock, Arkansas, retailer is being awarded such high damages.

    I’ve looked back through the most recent 10-K and 10-Q filings for Dillard’s and can’t find any reference to the JDA-i2 lawsuit in the legal proceedings section of the reports to the Securities and Exchange Commission. There is a reference in the 2000 annual report saying that the company is installing i2 software “to track historical customer demand” to better match supply to demand in its stores. None of its filings mention JDA. So whatever went wrong, the two companies are keeping it to themselves.

    In early 2001, i2 and footwear giant Nike tangled over an implementation of i2’s supply chain software that Nike contended caused too much of some products and too little of others to its customers, and hence hurt Nike’s bottom line. At the time, i2 told Computerworld that Nike was undergoing a very complex, $400 million ERP installation and i2’s products represented about 10 percent of that. The Nike installation required lots of customization and was “unusually challenging.” A few weeks later, i2 company president, Greg Brady, said in an interview in InformationWeek that whatever Nike’s problems were, it wasn’t because of i2’s software. In this case, the courts were kept out of it.

    As you might imagine, JDA’s lawyers are very quickly working on an appeal of the verdict. “We believe this verdict is unjustified given the nature of this commercial dispute,” said Hamish Brewer, JDA’s chief executive officer in a statement announcing the Texas verdict in the suit. “We will pursue every avenue available to overturn the verdict, and are confident that justice will ultimately prevail. In the meantime, we will continue to focus on providing our customers with world-class services and products.”

    All of this points out that something we brought up a few weeks ago: Companies are not as keen to roll with the punches when software projects don’t pan out as planned, and there is a growing concern that ISVs will be held accountable and liable for functional flaws and security vulnerabilities in their code. (See Lawsuit Raises Fear of Greater Liability Exposure for ISVs.)

    RELATED STORIES

    JDA Software Takes Another Run at i2 Technologies

    JDA Recovers Nicely in the Second Quarter

    JDA Plots Course Forward for MMS, and–Surprise–It’s Java

    JDA Previews New GUI for MMS at User Conference

    JDA Sales Hampered and Profits Slammed by Downturn in Q1

    JDA to Buy Back Shares as Retailers Hope for an Uptick in 2009

    Net Loss Doesn’t Prevent JDA’s Record Q4, Year

    JDA and i2 Call the Whole Thing Off

    JDA Shakes Off the Bad Economy, Sets Sales Record in Q3

    JDA Ponies Up $346 Million to Buy i2 Technologies

    JDA Software Has Its Best First Quarter Ever

    JDA Focuses on ‘Slow and Erratic’ Product Forecasting with E3

    JDA Elaborates on Supply Chain Strategy, But Questions Remain

    JDA Completes Manugistics Deal, Warns of Weaker Second Quarter Results

    JDA’s Development Roadmap Features iSeries in Supporting Role



                         Post this story to del.icio.us
                   Post this story to Digg
        Post this story to Slashdot

    Share this:

    • Reddit
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Email

    Tags: Tags: mtfh_rc, Volume 19, Number 23 -- June 21, 2010

    Sponsored by
    Chilli IT

    Chilli is one of the UKs leading IBM support and management providers with 20 years’ experience in the power and storage industry. Our bespoke solutions for maintenance, security and infrastructure delivers a service which is cost effective, increases productivity and enhances efficiency. Our ethical approach and unrivalled knowledge has secured business partnerships with blue-chip companies in the technology, retail, banking and travel sectors.

    As an IBM Business Partner, we provide you with the peace of mind that you are working in partnership with a company accredited to the highest standard. Our team of experts have worked together for many years and deliver projects which include consolidation, High Availability, Operating System upgrades; and backup and recovery installations.

    Contact us to see how we can help your business with IBM support and management.

    www.chilli-it.co.uk

    info@chilli–it.co.uk

    Share this:

    • Reddit
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Email

    How Do I Tell These Partitions Apart? Original Launches Overarching Tool for Quality Management

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

TFH Volume: 19 Issue: 23

This Issue Sponsored By

    Table of Contents

    • i/OS 7.1 Marks a Change in the JVM Guard
    • The AS/400 at 22: Yesterday and Forever
    • IBM Adds Power7 Boxes to Trade-In Deals
    • As I See It: Against All Currents
    • SaaS Surfs the Cash Conservation Wave
    • JDA Software’s i2 Unit Smacked with $246 Million Judgment
    • Another Indicator Says the IT Job Market Is Improving
    • Disk Array Sales Are Spinning Up, Says IDC
    • IBM Chops Maintenance on a Whole Bunch of Old Stuff
    • Newsflash: Developers Hate to Test Their Software

    Content archive

    • The Four Hundred
    • Four Hundred Stuff
    • Four Hundred Guru

    Recent Posts

    • IBM i 7.3 TR12: The Non-TR Tech Refresh
    • IBM i Integration Elevates Operational Query and Analytics
    • Simplified IBM i Stack Bundling Ahead Of Subscription Pricing
    • More Price Hikes From IBM, Now For High End Storage
    • Big Blue Readies Power10 And IBM i 7.5 Training for Partners
    • IBM Delivers More Out-of-the-Box Security with IBM i 7.5
    • Groundhog Day For Malware
    • IBM i Community Reacts to IBM i 7.5
    • Four Hundred Monitor, May 11
    • IBM i PTF Guide, Volume 24, Number 19

    Subscribe

    To get news from IT Jungle sent to your inbox every week, subscribe to our newsletter.

    Pages

    • About Us
    • Contact
    • Contributors
    • Four Hundred Monitor
    • IBM i PTF Guide
    • Media Kit
    • Subscribe

    Search

    Copyright © 2022 IT Jungle

    loading Cancel
    Post was not sent - check your email addresses!
    Email check failed, please try again
    Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email.