• The Four Hundred
  • Subscribe
  • Media Kit
  • Contributors
  • About Us
  • Contact
Menu
  • The Four Hundred
  • Subscribe
  • Media Kit
  • Contributors
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Trial Date Set in Vision-Maxava Case

    October 1, 2012 Alex Woodie

    An April trial date has been set in the false advertising and trade libel case that IBM i high availability software maker Maxava brought against its rival Vision Solutions and the reseller Sirius Computer Solutions. A jury in a Los Angeles courtroom will decide the case next spring–unless the two sides agree to a settlement or the trial is delayed once more.

    Maxava and Vision have been going at it since December 2009, when Maxava filed its false advertising lawsuit in U.S. District Court Central District of California Western Division, based in Los Angeles. Maxava (which at that time went by the name Maximum Availability) initially alleged that Vision distributed advertising materials that contained false information about Maxava’s business and its products, and that these materials damaged its business. The court granted Maxava a temporary injunction against Vision in the middle of 2010.

    In October 2010, Maxava widened the suit to include allegations of trade libel, interfering with prospective economic advantage, anti-competitive, monopolistic behavior in violation of the Sherman Act, and Lanham Act violations. It also succeeded in adding Vision’s business partner Sirius to the lawsuit after an earlier attempt had been rejected by the court.

    Vision and Sirius deny all of the charges, and have repeatedly asked the court to dismiss the case for lack of evidence. Attorneys for the companies say Maxava has failed to prove key aspects of its case, including whether Vision’s alleged actions had a “significant adverse effect” on Maxava’s business. By Maxava’s own admission, Vision argues, Maxava’s market share has grown while Vision’s has eroded. The defendants have also accused the plaintiff of abusing the discovery phase of the lawsuit by using it as a means for finding evidence that will make their case. Maxava says it needed discovery to find out how widespread Vision’s misconduct was.

    The allegedly misleading statements were contained in several pieces of marketing material that Vision admits it gave to direct-sale prospects for its iTera Echo2 software, and provided for resellers like Sirius to use with their prospects. Maxava says it believes the materials were used from the middle of 2007, and perhaps earlier, and it didn’t discover them until late 2009, the company says in court filings.

    In particular, Maxava says the following statements made by Vision about Maxava’s products and business were false: that 80 customers have replaced *noMAX (now called Maxava HA) with Vision’s software; that Maxava has a limited support staff in New Zealand and an immature partner network; that Maxava doesn’t offer 24/7 global support; that *noMAX takes more than 30 minutes to manage every day; that *noMax requires custom coding; that *noMax is built for small and midsize businesses, and not enterprises; that *noMax takes more than 30 days to install; that more than half of *noMax customers don’t know if they are ready for a role swap; and that more than 80 percent of customers have never done a role swap test.

    While Vision admits to writing and distributing the documents, it says they didn’t have a big impact on its competitor. In particular, Vision says Maxava can’t identify any customer or sale that it lost because of the alleged false representations; can’t prove that the claims in the documents are false; can’t prove that any “reasonable” consumer would be swayed by its alleged false statements; can’t prove that Vision’s salespeople were “deceptive” or malicious; and can’t prove that their actions were material.

    A November 2011 trial date was initially set, but the trial was delayed. In December 2011, Judge George Wu issued a tentative ruling in favor of Vision and Sirius on most of the claims in Maxava’s suit. In particular, he favored Vision’s argument that none of the six customers that received misleading material from Vision–including Roger Cleveland Golf, Silverleaf Resorts, Hyundai Information Services of North America, Kingston Technologies, Panda Restaurant Group, and Bradley Corp–were actually deceived. In fact, four of those customers went on to buy *noMAX licenses. “There is no evidence in this case that any of the alleged misrepresentations made by Vision had any impact on any customer’s or potential customer’s purchasing decision,” Judge Wu wrote in his preliminary ruling.

    Activity in this case has waxed and waned over the past year. Several months will go by with no new documents filed, and then there will be a flurry. Many of the documents filed lately have been sealed (at the requests of the plaintiff and defendant) to prevent the prying eyes of the press from seeing them. Several IBM i shops that were in the market for HA software have been called in to testify, and customer lists have been discussed. The seal was approved, ostensibly to protect the privacy of these customers.

    Attempts at mediation and out-of-court settlements–which is how 90 percent of civil lawsuits end–have failed to generate a deal that is amenable to both parties. If the course of the lawsuit doesn’t change between now and April 2, Maxava will finally have its day in court.

    RELATED STORIES

    Judge Tentatively Rules For Vision In Maxava False Advertising Suit

    Vision and Maxava Prep for November Trial

    Judge Issues Protective Order in Maxava Versus Vision Solutions Suit

    Maxava Widens Vision Lawsuit, Sues Sirius

    Maximum Availability Sues Vision Solutions Over Advertising Claims



                         Post this story to del.icio.us
                   Post this story to Digg
        Post this story to Slashdot

    Share this:

    • Reddit
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Email

    Tags:

    Sponsored by
    VISUAL LANSA 16 WEBINAR

    Trying to balance stability and agility in your IBM i environment?

    Join this webinar and explore Visual LANSA 16 – our enhanced professional low-code platform designed to help organizations running on IBM i evolve seamlessly for what’s next.

    🎙️VISUAL LANSA 16 WEBINAR

    Break Monolithic IBM i Applications and Unlock New Value

    Explore modernization without rewriting. Decouple monolithic applications and extend their value through integration with modern services, web frameworks, and cloud technologies.

    🗓️ July 10, 2025

    ⏰ 9 AM – 10 AM CDT (4 PM to 5 PM CEST)

    See the webinar schedule in your time zone

    Register to join the webinar now

    What to Expect

    • Get to know Visual LANSA 16, its core features, latest enhancements, and use cases
    • Understand how you can transition to a MACH-aligned architecture to enable faster innovation
    • Discover native REST APIs, WebView2 support, cloud-ready Azure licensing, and more to help transform and scale your IBM i applications

    Read more about V16 here.

    Share this:

    • Reddit
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn
    • Twitter
    • Email

    Oak Bank Looks to Grow with New Fiserv Banking System Coglin Mill Reaches Out to Salesforce.com with ETL Connector

    Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Volume 21, Number 35 -- October 1, 2012
THIS ISSUE SPONSORED BY:

Maxava
New Generation Software
Abacus Solutions
Tributary Systems
IntelliChief

Table of Contents

  • Some Things To Ponder On The Impending Power7+ Era
  • iBelieve NY: If You Don’t Like Change. . .
  • Arming The IBM i Nation
  • Mad Dog 21/21: Shamoon And Six Trends
  • IBM’s Rometty Takes Over As Chairman Of The Board
  • Jack Henry Busts Through $1 Billion Barrier In Fiscal 2012
  • External Disk Array Sales Slow Down A Bit
  • Trial Date Set in Vision-Maxava Case
  • IBM Fishes For Managed Service Providers; Nice Bait
  • IBM Gives A Deal To Online Software Buyers

Content archive

  • The Four Hundred
  • Four Hundred Stuff
  • Four Hundred Guru

Recent Posts

  • Liam Allan Shares What’s Coming Next With Code For IBM i
  • From Stable To Scalable: Visual LANSA 16 Powers IBM i Growth – Launching July 8
  • VS Code Will Be The Heart Of The Modern IBM i Platform
  • The AS/400: A 37-Year-Old Dog That Loves To Learn New Tricks
  • IBM i PTF Guide, Volume 27, Number 25
  • Meet The Next Gen Of IBMers Helping To Build IBM i
  • Looks Like IBM Is Building A Linux-Like PASE For IBM i After All
  • Will Independent IBM i Clouds Survive PowerVS?
  • Now, IBM Is Jacking Up Hardware Maintenance Prices
  • IBM i PTF Guide, Volume 27, Number 24

Subscribe

To get news from IT Jungle sent to your inbox every week, subscribe to our newsletter.

Pages

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Contributors
  • Four Hundred Monitor
  • IBM i PTF Guide
  • Media Kit
  • Subscribe

Search

Copyright © 2025 IT Jungle