Volume 17, Number 21 -- May 27, 2008

The Way IBM Sees New Versus Prior i Platforms

Published: May 27, 2008

by Timothy Prickett Morgan

In the wake of any major server launch, IBM's top marketeers have usually put together two sets of comparisons for IBM's own sales reps and its business partner resellers. One set of comparisons looks at the new product line and compares and contrasts it with the immediately prior product line, usually highlighting scalability increases or price/performance improvements for given configurations. In the AS/400 family, IBM used to make a lot more comparisons to Unix and other proprietary platforms, too, which helped customers remain confident that the platform was competitive.

The latter type of competitive platform comparisons are not usually available to the public, and are especially thin on the ground in recent years as the iSeries and System i platform did not keep pace with the insane price/performance improvements available in the Windows servers that now dominate the small and medium business arena. IBM has always been very good about giving lots of relative performance metrics within the OS/400 and i5/OS product line, and in recent years has been happy to even share priced configuration comparisons--real-world comparisons--as it moved from server generation to generation. This has all been helpful for OS/400 and i5/OS shops who need to make the technical and economic arguments for upgrading to newer platforms.

But this time around, with the Power Systems family of launches, the data seems to be sparse. While the IBMers I have spoken to have said I should take a look at the aggressive pricing for maintenance on the new machines versus earlier System i boxes--which I will do in the coming weeks--it has been difficult to get the kind of platform comparisons I am used to getting my hands on. This, I believe, is a function of executives moving from the former System i division, where they did their homework, to the Power Systems division, where the AIX folks maybe did their homework in comparing old and new AIX platforms or maybe they didn't. In the Unix world, where there is actual competition, you don't worry about comparisons to last year's model of your own gear as you do about how you look next to this year's model coming out of Hewlett-Packard or Sun Microsystems.

As I explained in last week's issue, by IBM's own reckoning, the vast majority of the i platform sales in 2008 will be for entry machines in the line, which include last year's user-priced i5 515 and 525 boxes and this year's Power 520 M15 and M25 boxes. And according to the documents I have seen, IBM has not priced the entry configurations much differently between Power5+ and Power6 systems, and the performance is not radically different, either. This, I think, is absolutely intentional.

I have waded through a number of different presentations that IBM put together for sales reps and business partners, and over and over again it says the same thing. First, that by moving to the System p pricing structure for hardware, what would have been called the System i (but is now a Power Systems box running i 6.1) has more competitive hardware pricing. That means the new machinery is competitive with other Unix and OpenVMS gear, presumably, which is what IBM is pricing against because i for Business is a serious business platform. (The fact that most SMB shops don't know what i5/OS, Unix, OpenVMS, or Linux is seems to be beside the point. . . .) The other phrasing you hear, again and again, and this has to be something that the System i reseller channel must have been pushing for, is to "maintain the total solution price." In plain English, that means the difference in price and price/performance between the System i 515 and 525 and the equivalent Power Systems boxes just launched will be minimal. Take a look for yourself at IBM's own presentation.

What IBM calls this, as you can see, is reflecting the value of the System i in the i software stack instead of in the hardware, where I have argued (since 1993, I think) that IBM should not have put it in the first place. (Big Blue had other needs, such as artificially inflating hardware revenues in the 1990s and early 2000s, but I think this practice really hurt the competitive stance of the AS/400 and its follow-ons.) As you can see from the chart above, there is not a big difference between the Power 520 and its System i 515 predecessor; the base M25 has a lot less expensive hardware price than the 525, by IBM's reckoning, but the software bill makes the newer box only slight less costly.

IBM has good reason to try to keep the prices all the same, despite the competitive pressures from Windows boxes that now have four cores per socket. It has to give the reseller channel enough margin to invest in the relatively hard sell of pushing Power6 servers running either i5/OS V5R4 or i 6.1 rather than just give up and push Windows and a migration strategy away from the i platform. Whether or not this is a smart long-term strategy remains to be seen, but this is the play that IBM's marketeers are calling.

The other differentiation that IBM is making between the System i 515 and 525 and the new Power 520 is that the older boxes support i5/OS V5R4, which many customers can more easily certify their applications on since i 6.1 requires program conversion. (See i5/OS V6R1: The TIMI, It Is A-Changing and i5/OS V6R1 Compatibility an Issue for Software Vendors for more on that.) Moreover, customers who need to support legacy twinax devices and quarter-inch tape drives have to go with a 515 or 525, since these are not supported on the new Power 520. The other thing IBM is stressing in its presentations is that maintenance is lower on the new boxes than on the older ones, but just how much different, it has not said. (Presumably someone has done that math, but I haven't seen it yet so I am working to do it myself.)

Perhaps more significant is the suggestion by IBM that for many customers on Power5+ System i 520 boxes, it will be less expensive to move to the user-priced i 525 than to go with a Power6-based M25 machine. The main reason is that the upgrade from the old 520 to the 525 allows for the reuse of many parts within the system (memory cards, peripheral cards, disk drives, and such), while the jump to the M25 means replacing a lot of these components.

This doesn't sound like a very aggressive plan to push Power6 iron, and I think this is no accident. I can't prove anything, but the pricing and packaging of the i variants of the entry Power Systems machines leads me to believe that IBM still is not getting good yields on the chips. IBM is just as happy to peddle Power5+ machines in 2008, and I would guess for good reason. It wants every Power6 chip it can make to end up in an AIX box, a blade server, or a high-end AIX or i enterprise-class server. I would have expected IBM to compete more aggressively on price/performance if chip yields were higher, and the fact that IBM is offering customers a 10 percent performance bump (if they don't end up being memory or disk constrained in their configurations) at essentially the same price is a telling fact.

In any event, I will be ginning up more precise comparisons than the ones I have seen from IBM to give you a sense of where things actually stand over the course of the past several i-related products.

One final note. Brian Podrow, a long-time AS/400 manager within IBM and lately a Power Systems product manager for the Americas group, has retired from Big Blue after 34 years, effective April 30. Like many IBMers, Podrow started out with the System/3 line in Rochester, and has been one of the key thinkers behind the positioning of the AS/400, iSeries, and System i lines. In the past decade, since I have known of Podrow, he has worked behind the scenes to support resellers and IBM's direct sales force with the Quick Pricers and competitive analysis documents that are a vital part of sales and marketing of the platform. While I was never officially supposed to have such documents, I can say from personal experience that Podrow's work has helped clarify IBM's positioning to me in a detailed manner that you just do not get anywhere else inside of IBM or among any other IT suppliers, for that matter. Podrow and I did not always agree on what some data point in the product line might mean, or what IBM could or should do next to be more competitive, but his work on behalf of the AS/400 and its progeny was nothing short of prodigious, and vital, too. Brian, I hope that means something coming from a blabbermouth like me. I mean it sincerely, and I wish you all the best as you take your well-deserved vacation and pursue the business opportunities you have put on hold for 35 years. Thanks, from all of us. Your work is already missed.


The i5 515 and 525: IBM's Competitive Analysis

The Demographics of i Sales and Shipments

IBM Previews "Blue Business" SMB System Sales Approach

Let's Unscramble IBM's Server Sales in Q1 2008 a Little

It's Official: Now We're Power Systems and i for Business

The 64-Core Power6-Based Power 595 Starts to Roll in May

And Then There Was One: The New and Improved Power 570

Power6 Chips Get i Support in New Entry and Blade Machines

Progress Is Our Most Important Product

Entry System p Servers Get Power6 Chips, System i Boxes Await

Some Info on i5/OS V6R1 and V6R2 Support

IBM Aims for Server Expansion in 2008, Including System i Reincarnation

A New Year, A New IBM Systems and Technology Group

IBM Creates New Power, SMB Server Divisions

                     Post this story to
               Post this story to Digg
    Post this story to Slashdot

Sponsored By

MoshiMoshi Episode 2 Now Showing

Win a license of Messenger or Star Trek DVDs

I.T. Manager Harold Stanley has found himself
in a predicament, and it could mean a free license
of Bytware's Messenger or the complete first
season of Star Trek for you.

Just watch "The Tape Trap," take the quiz, and you could win!

See the episode and take the quiz now!

Editor: Timothy Prickett Morgan
Contributing Editors: Dan Burger, Joe Hertvik, Brian Kelly, Shannon O'Donnell,
Mary Lou Roberts, Victor Rozek, Kevin Vandever, Hesh Wiener, Alex Woodie
Publisher and Advertising Director: Jenny Thomas
Advertising Sales Representative: Kim Reed
Contact the Editors: To contact anyone on the IT Jungle Team
Go to our contacts page and send us a message.

Sponsored Links

COMMON:  Join us at the Focus 2008 workshop conference, October 5 - 8, in San Francisco, California
Help/Systems:  Explore operations automation and BI, June 17 - 20, 2008, Minneapolis, MN
Vision Solutions:  System i Management Tips Blog - Free i5/OS Tips Each Week!



IT Jungle Store Top Book Picks

Easy Steps to Internet Programming for AS/400, iSeries, and System i: List Price, $49.95
Getting Started with PHP for i5/OS: List Price, $59.95
The System i RPG & RPG IV Tutorial and Lab Exercises: List Price, $59.95
The System i Pocket RPG & RPG IV Guide: List Price, $69.95
The iSeries Pocket Database Guide: List Price, $59.00
The iSeries Pocket Developers' Guide: List Price, $59.00
The iSeries Pocket SQL Guide: List Price, $59.00
The iSeries Pocket Query Guide: List Price, $49.00
The iSeries Pocket WebFacing Primer: List Price, $39.00
Migrating to WebSphere Express for iSeries: List Price, $49.00
iSeries Express Web Implementer's Guide: List Price, $59.00
Getting Started with WebSphere Development Studio for iSeries: List Price, $79.95
Getting Started With WebSphere Development Studio Client for iSeries: List Price, $89.00
Getting Started with WebSphere Express for iSeries: List Price, $49.00
WebFacing Application Design and Development Guide: List Price, $55.00
Can the AS/400 Survive IBM?: List Price, $49.00
The All-Everything Machine: List Price, $29.95
Chip Wars: List Price, $29.95

The Linux Beacon
NYSE Euronext Trades Mainframes and Unix for Linux and X64

Canonical Founder Calls for Synchronized Linux Releases

AMD Ships Low-Power Barcelonas as Two More Execs Exit

New and Updated Barcelona Boxes Debut from Sun

VMware Tweaks Virtualization Stack, Boasts of Greenness and Sales

Four Hundred Stuff
Symantec Combats Phishing with New Services Offering

BCD Slings a New C#-Based GUI with Catapult 7.0

SkyView and Innovatum Formalize Partnership with New Product

Profound Eliminates OLTP Requirement with Web Enablement Software

140 Apps and (Hopefully) Counting for i 6.1

Big Iron
NYSE Euronext Trades Mainframes and Unix for Linux and X64

Top Mainframe Stories From Around the Web

Chats, Webinars, Seminars, Shows, and Other Happenings

Four Hundred Guru
Use PCOMM Scripts to Dynamically Build a Spreadsheet, Part 2

Use SQL to Strip Out Tab Characters

Admin Alert: Monitoring the Monitors

System i PTF Guide
May 17, 2008: Volume 10, Number 20

May 10, 2008: Volume 10, Number 19

May 3, 2008: Volume 10, Number 18

April 26, 2008: Volume 10, Number 17

April 19, 2008: Volume 10, Number 16

April 12, 2008: Volume 10, Number 15

The Windows Observer
Micro-Hoo is Back On the Table, But In a Different Form

Developers Cool to Vista, Evans Study Finds

Global Sales Save HP's Financial Cookies in the Second Quarter

Symantec Combats Phishing with New Services Offering

Microsoft Heads Aberdeen's List of Top 100 Tech Companies

The Unix Guardian
Global Sales Save HP's Financial Cookies in the Second Quarter

NYSE Euronext Trades Mainframes and Unix for Linux and X64

Sun Updates VirtualBox with Native Solaris Support

HP Ships Insight Dynamics for Managing Physical and Virtual Machines

A Word Cloud of IBM Server Brand Names

Four Hundred Monitor
Four Hundred Monitor's
Full iSeries Events Calendar


Seagull Software

Printer Friendly Version

The Way IBM Sees New Versus Prior i Platforms

The Server Biz Enjoys the X64 Upgrade Cycle in Q1

Evans Data Ranks Integrated Development Environments

As I See It: The Programmer as Artist

Reseller Mainline to Acquire Competitor Cornerstone

But Wait, There's More:

COMMON Belgium Shifts Focus from i to IBM SMB . . . That Windows-on-Power Rumor Surfaces Again . . . CDW Survey Says IT Shouldn't Wear Green on Its Sleeves . . . Magic Software Boosts Sales, But Profits Under Pressure in Q1 . . . The IT Services Business Keeps On A-Growing . . .

The Four Hundred


Subscription Information:
You can unsubscribe, change your email address, or sign up for any of IT Jungle's free e-newsletters through our Web site at

Copyright © 1996-2008 Guild Companies, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guild Companies, Inc., 50 Park Terrace East, Suite 8F, New York, NY 10034

Privacy Statement